I've talked to Nick, Mom, and bridesmaids and we've decided to add another color to the palette, but only for the reception. So, without further ado (I love that word, I never really knew what it meant until I watched 'Much Ado About Nothing')
Ceremony: Red & white (just like before)
Reception: Red, white, and...orange!
That's right, orange. I was trying to find an Asiatic lily, or similar type, in true red, but was only finding burgundy and pink. I ran across this picture and really liked how the color popped.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/893d4/893d43a3874991a0c6147365edd8f53bc03eeb1d" alt="Photobucket"
I really love this picture, taken at Matangi Resort in Fiji. It has been the inspiration for the new color scheme:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/147dd/147dd3202c2b6acd5d5d750920c828cd8ee910d3" alt="Photobucket"
Here is a collage that I made, hopefully it doesn't look like a bunch of totally random pictures, but makes sense regarding my scheme.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fa667/fa66700242b3d0b4c84fed947cadfe1d15fd2c7b" alt="Photobucket"
So now our flowers have slightly changed regarding the reception; the ceremony will be the same as before, colors and everything. So here I go again:
Ceremony:My bouquet-red & white long stemmed calla lilies wrapped w/ red & white ribbon & Nanna's pearls
MOH bouquet-red long stemmed calla lilies wrapped w/ white (or red) ribbon
BMs bouquets-white long stemmed calla lilies wrapped w/red ribbon
JBs bouquets-white short stemmed bouquets wrapped w/ red ribbon
Boutonnieres & corsages-white & red mini calla lilies, going to depend on what the guys wear as to which color of flower they wear
Reception:Cake-decorated with orange Asiatic lilies
Centerpieces-red & orange fruit & white (silk probably) mini calla lilies
Does any of that make sense? Be honest now, what do you think?
Picture sources:
Orange lilies,
Sunset, Bridal party posing: Victoria Souza Photography, Bride hair: Project Wedding, Red wedding dress: , Heart in hands: , Hands in Sand: ,
Matangi treehouse, Calla lily bouquet: ,
Card box,
Cake topper,
Cake,
Ring dish